back to home page current issues who is eeg news archive image archive green links East Gippsland forest issues logo    
  Spring 2006  

FROM CROSS CUT SAWS TO COMPUTERS

It started off with cross cut saws and bullocks, then to chainsaws and bulldozers, now the future is in computerised harvesting machines in plantations.

Three-way solution

The logging union has recently been outraged about the need to import skilled workers to fill the new jobs in the plantation industry. They have also been outraged about the loss of jobs in native forest logging. We 'greenies' have been outraged about the logging of forests for the past 30 years. The solution is now staring everyone in the face. Environmentalists saw it coming long ago but the others are still just catching up.

1,000 jobs

There are 300,000ha of plantations in western Victoria and the Green Triangle. They will soon need up to 1,100 workers to start processing the trees. Hi-tech computerised harvesters and the new machines being used. In late August Howard offered to trial a new relocation plan for workers to get up to $5,000 to move to where the jobs are. It's all there just waiting to fall into place. In the past, the industry and union has been too busy arguing about access to native forests to see what was looming ahead. It's now staring right at them.

The logging industry has always had a large transient work force. There should be plenty who would jump at this opportunity. For those who have established their homes and lives in East Gippsland, they could either move into the low volume high value end of the market or take on work that the growing tourism industry will be offering. Not in selling Devonshire teas but in building and maintaining tourism infrastructure.

Enter Mr Bracks

The transfer of jobs to plantations is occurring. The dirty dangerous work and insecure future of logging forests should now be relegated to the history books. We just need Mr Bracks to help this transition occur smoothly and offer training for those who want it. We will then have a conflict free wood products industry and our native forests left standing.

Jill

Back to news archive

 

Orange-bellied Parrot

saving the marginal seated Broadbent - "kissing an uninterested parrot"Federal Environment Minister, Ian Campbell, has promised $3.2 million to help save the OBP. The endangered parrot gained attention when it was used as a tool to stop the controversial windfarm in Liberal member, Russell Braodbent's seat.

 

 

 

 

 

Back to news archive

 

OLDIES FOR OLD GROWTH

A group of senior citizens have joined the campaign to stop logging in East Gippsland's old-growth forests.

So far they have over 50 supporters and members and numbers are growing. OFOG have adopted the slogan, Respect your Elders - Protect Old-Growth Forests. Spokesman for the group, Wolf Passauer, says it will lobby the Government in the lead-up to the state election. Politicians think that only the young are concerned about destruction of our environment. This group should shatter that image and let the government know that older voters are also annoyed by Mr Bracks letting loggers and woodchippers destroy our forest elders.

If you'd like to get in touch with OFOG, call Wolf on 9751 1571 or 0412 398 496 or write to 5 Yurnga Ave, Olinda, 3788,

Jill

Back to news archive

 

WHERE DOES CRAIG INGRAM STAND ON LOGGING FORESTS???

Our Gippsland East Independent pollie, Craig Ingram, has the image of a champion for our rivers. You'd think this concern for the water would spill over to include our rivers' catchments, but not so. His attitudes to logging forests were spelled out very clearly in the Herald Sun and on the ABC in early September.
Here's a summary of his comments'

The conservation movement's attempts to save old growth would threaten 500 jobs in East Gippsland.

  • Voters in Cann River, Orbost and on into Bairnsdale want these forests logged.
  • Not being able to log would devastate his community.
  • He asked the Lib/Labs to keep logging old growth forests and protect the industry.
  • There's 85% of old-growth already reserved.
  • Banning logging in old-growth forests would hit saw-millers hard.
  • He agreed that we conservationists were very organised and were spending as much time in Parliament House as politicians.

The last point he had right. The rest were simply regurgitated mistruths and rhetoric from industry bosses. Five hundred jobs? That was the estimated number of jobs 10 years ago when there were about 20 mills operating. Now there are six. Most old growth already reserved? - far from it!

Craig Ingram is using out of date information, ignoring a huge swathe of his voters and trying to impress a small band of blue singlets. This will be at the cost of losing a much bigger band of past supporters.

Please call his electoral office and leave him a message -
5152 3491, fax 5152 2023 or email him on
craig.ingram@parliament.vic.gov.au, or even write to him:
PO Box 443 Bairnsdale 3875

Jill

Back to news archive

 

REFLEX PAPER - 100% HOODWINK

Reflex Paper 100% Aussie Made - Mate!The latest porky to come from the makers of Reflex paper, is that their product is now 100% forest sensitive, in fact it's so eco-friendly it is bursting with endangered species.

Australia's biggest paper company, PaperlinX in the Latrobe Valley, is congratulating itself for this bodgie eco-label given by the normally reliable Forest Stewardship Council certification scheme.

Bottom rung tick-off
In fact it has only the lesser FSC 'Chain of Custody' Certification for its Reflex paper. To get this tick it needs to have 59% of its woodchips come from properly FSC certified sources, like a well-managed plantation. The other 41% can come from any government approved forest (rainforest, threatened species habitat etc). As long as it's not 'illegally taken'.

FSC duped?
So where does the supposed eco-friendly wood come from? Considering that Paperlinx still takes 59% of its pulp from the Central Highlands' water catchments, old growth and Leadbeaters Possum habitat as well as importing Tasmania's forests, this claim is very unconvincing. Even the logs they buy from Hancocks' plantations in South Gippsland are only under interim FSC certification. Hancocks' interim certification has been reviewed because they breached so many environmental principles. That report is being firmly sat upon.

100% Australian hoodwinkery
We are told this 'demonstrates the PaperlinX commitment to environmental principles through the entire paper chain'. More like a commitment to keep hoodwinking the public with half truths. And we are reassured that all this is 'Australian made'! That is - it comes from our very own native forests supporting Aussie native wildlife that are crushed under bulldozers driven by Aussie blokes, daily. Something to be proud of!

EEG and our regional sister group, The Central Highlands Alliance, is currently asking some very tough questions of the certifying body.

Jill

Back to news archive

 

QUOLLS

A recent scientific survey of the impact of the 2003 fire in the upper Snowy River on Tiger Quolls calculates a reduction in the quoll population of between 67.5-90%. The impact of this loss on the state population (without taking into account the impact of the 2003 fires from the north-east through the Alps and Gippsland) would be between 33-45% reduction.

Given the ongoing decline in range and abundance of quolls in Victoria a sudden decline of this magnitude should be sounding the sirens.

Dasyurus maculatus, the Tiger (or Spot-Tailed) Quoll had been Studied and monitored in the Suggan Buggan valley since 1990. In February 2003, the alpine wildfires burnt through the Suggan Buggan Valley and Rocky Range.

Quolls love rocky outcrops and have certain areas where they leave their droppings. These are called latrine sites. These were surveyed in the study area to record the animals' presence.

Searches were undertaken in April 2003, February-March and October 2004 and October 2005 over many known sites. Presence/absence was then compared to fire intensity. Evidence of quolls surviving was found at five sites that were either unburnt or patchily burnt at low intensity. Sites where quolls were not recorded included the north-facing escarpment along the Suggan Buggan Valley an area that burnt very hot.

The Upper Snowy River has had a consistent record of quolls for the past 25 years. Approximately 90% of the white box/cypress pine on both sides of the Snowy River burnt intensely. The only areas either unburnt or burnt patchily were sections of the Suggan Buggan valley, Gattamurah Creek, the Snowy River valley and Little River Gorge.

Quolls did survive in areas that didn't burn so intensely. The fact that quolls, and their prey were still absent from the escarpment more than two and a half years after the fire suggests they did not survive the fire. Given their nationally endangered status and slowness to recolonise this is a serious dive in the state's population of this amazing pouched meat-eater.

Jill

Back to news archive

 

Water bandits

'If the logging industry was an irrigator they would be charged millions for using this water'

Melbourne's catchments are empty, so we're looking at the skies searching for rain. Right idea, but wrong direction. Look at the Thomson dam, and ask why we still allow clearfell logging in its catchment, then look at Steve Bracks and ask him.

Logging our forested reserves creates muddy run-off, incredibly thirsty new tree crops, and cheap woodchips for paper pulp. Natural mature forest sits there quietly filtering rainwater, while it produces wildlife habitat, clean air and breathtaking beauty.

We have a choice between water restrictions for us, or logging restrictions for the makers of Reflex paper.

PaperlinX takes most of the trees from Melbourne's water catchments to make Reflex copy paper. Political influences (and donations) form PaperlinX has caused successive governments to turn a blind eye to catchment destruction and loss of water.

Clearfelling creates vast areas of fast growing young trees. Young trees soak up much more water than a mature forest. For over 50 years the water yield from these areas is reduced by half. Then the trees are planned to be cut down again. This sentences our water catchments to permanent drought.

Liz / Jill / Sarah

Back to news archive

 

Dam good decision

The Victorian Farmers Federation (VFF) and the National Party has criticised the Bracks Government for plans to ban new dams on 18 Victorian rivers. Under the plan, the Snowy, Mitchell, Genoa, Aberfeldy, Thomson, Bemm and Upper Buchan rivers could not be dammed. The VFF said it was wasting water that would just go out to sea. They see our rivers as just bothersome big drainage ditches.

Interesting to note that the Nats in Queensland are opposed to the two controversial dams the Beattie Government is planning to build. Why? It doesn't benefit farmers, only Brisbane. Yet in Victoria, the Nats are all for dams, because farmers want them.

East Gippy drinking water gets filthier

Contracts have been let and construction set to begin on water treatment plants that will give five small towns in East Gippsland clean water. The Authority is investing $7.7 M in water quality improvements for Bemm River, Buchan, Cann River, Swifts Creek and Nowa Nowa.

The common theme with all these towns is that they have serious logging activity in their water catchments. Yet another cost to us compliments of the logging industry.

Jill / Pipeline - East Gippsland Water June '06

Back to news archive

 

Forest flambé plans thwarted

Despite plans to burn 130,000ha of bush last season DSE only managed a massive 49,000ha. The year before 127,000ha was scorched and before that 95,000ha of healthy undergrowth ecology was turned to ash. Gippsland had a planned 54,000ha to be flambéd but only managed to dry out and modify 10,000ha.

Jill / Weekly Times 14.6.06

Back to news archive

 

Mill fire deliberate

The fire that burnt down the Orbost sawmill three weeks after it went broke in May, remains unsolved. The fire did about $200,000 damage to the company's offices where the books were being reviewed by the receivers. Forensic investigators concluded the fire was deliberately lit.

25.7.06 ABC news

Back to news archive

 

Federal threatened species Act ineffective

The Federal Environment Protection Biodiversity and Conservation Act is a waste of money, according to researchers at the Australia Institute. The Act is designed to protect threatened species and world heritage areas that may not be covered by state environment laws. The Institute's deputy director, Andrew Macintosh, says only four out of 1,900 developments have been blocked in six years of operation. So $15 - $30 million a year is spent on a law that isn't improving anything.

The Howard Government is doing virtually nothing to improve non-compliance with the law. In the vast majority of cases, the Minister is green-lighting developments and other impacts with very few appropriate conditions placed on them.

In the case of uranium mining and nuclear waste, the Government has simply overridden the environment act.

ABC radio via Wildlife Bytes 31.7.06

Back to news archive

 

YET MORE CASES OF ILLEGAL LOGGING
TIME FOR BRACKS TO CLEARFELL DSE

We have to wonder if we are in Indonesia or Australia sometimes. The latest incidents of government foresters approving illegal logging is in the Red Gum Forests at Barmah on the Murray River and in the Central Highlands.

Thompson catchment
World Water Week began on 20th of August - the same day that conservationists from the Central Highlands made the shocking discovery of illegal logging in Melbourne's most important water supply catchment. DSE forest managers marked and approved this operation - as in most other illegal logging operations that have been discovered over the years. Prosecutions and/or sackings must follow. Forester collusion or incompetence can no longer be tolerated and excused. The other option is to stop logging catchments.

There are minimal government standards to protect water quality but even these have been violated. The law states there is to be no logging from the 1st May until the 30th Nov each year to avoid run-off during winter that will send mud and silt into Melbourne's drinking water supplies (country town water supplies don't get such consideration).

Logging is forbidden during the wettest months to reduce the risk of dirty water and contamination. Sediment caused by logging reduces the effectiveness of chlorination, allowing waterborne diseases such as Giardia to thrive. Sarah Rees from The Central Highland's Alliance also found that logging coupe plans have never had this area mapped meaning the logging was approved but was in every way illegal.

Barmah Forests
Friends of the Earth sleuths uncovered an area where a contractor was instructed to illegally log four hectares outside an approved coupe boundary.

Less than 2% of Barmah's logging operations have been audited but already eight potential breaches have been reported. Breaches include illegal logging of six old growth Red Gums, crucial habitat for species like the threatened Squirrel Glider, Brush-tailed Phascogale and Superb Parrot. Not long ago a private land owner was told to pay a $10,000 bond and replant 1,000 trees for cutting down 28 old red gums on his property without permission (if not he could be liable of a fine up to $100,000).

Jill / TCHA / FOE

Back to news archive

 

1996 greens protest 2006 loggers protest "save our mills" "save the floorboards"IF YOU GO DOWN TO BUY WOOD TODAY YOU'RE IN FOR A BIG SUPRISE

Timber yards just don't bother stocking hardwood timber any more. Why?

It is because no one wants to buy hardwood timber. There are no uses for native forest hardwoods which pine and other plantation products cannot replace, and at a lower price.

Many sawmills that cut native forest logs are teetering on the brink of receivership. The industry is collapsing quickly. Here are some examples:

  • The largest sawmill in East Gippsland went into receivership in early June.
  • Up to half of all the remaining mills are near receivership.
  • The old stalwart of the industry, Micah's sawmill in Erica, is up for sale.
  • Neville Smith Timber Industries at Heyfield is the largest hardwood sawmill in Australia, yet only made $67,000 profit last year.
  • Terra Timbers at Bairnsdale was predicted to be the saviour of the east with millions of dollars investment in kiln driers for producing value added export timbers. It is also finding it difficult to sell its intended volumes.
  • Recent auctioning of timber at Fowles in Port Melbourne saw lots of hardwood timber left unsold, and those which did sell, went for 10% of their value.
  • Pine now makes up more than 80% of the market for building timbers. This dominance has been growing for the past 20 years. There are few applications where pine is not the preferred product.
  • The advent of the five star energy rating system favours concrete slabs over stumps and bearers, rough sawn hardwood's last toehold in house framing.
  • In buildings where sub-floor construction is still used, engineered and treated pine products are preferred. Laminate flooring and floating floors (made from pine) are a cheaper and better wearing than hardwood tongue and groove.
  • The Victorian Timber Promotion Council has folded. Hardwood timber marketing promotion campaigns (like 'eco select') have all but disappeared.

Pine has taken over as a building timber. Feature grade kiln dried products like tongue and groove flooring is the last hope for the state's hardwood sawmills. But it costs about the same as comparable hardwood flooring imported from Europe. Victorian sawn hardwood is now a specialty product precariously holding on to a niche that is shrinking by the day. There is no light at the end of the tunnel and it can only get worse.

Marcus Ward, architect / Jill

 

Back to news archive